Blockchain & IT/Home · Blockchain & IT

CLARITY Act Faces Rough Road... Passage Odds Fall from 35% to 18-19% as US Crypto Regulation Hinges on the '60-Vote' Threshold

The digital asset market structure bill, the so-called CLARITY Act, which has drawn attention for its potential to reshape the regulatory framework of the U.S. cryptocurrency market, is struggling at the Senate threshold. Republicans have released an amendment reflecting a considerable portion of De

Wooil Shim
Staff Reporter
14 min read
CLARITY Act Faces Rough Road... Passage Odds Fall from 35% to 18-19% as US Crypto Regulation Hinges on the '60-Vote' Threshold
CBC News

The digital asset market structure bill, the so-called CLARITY Act, which has drawn attention for its potential to reshape the regulatory framework of the U.S. cryptocurrency market, is struggling at the Senate threshold. Republicans have released an amendment reflecting a considerable portion of Democratic demands, but disagreements over ethics rules, stablecoins, consumer protection, and state regulatory authority remain unresolved, making the bill's prospects uncertain again. Markets once priced the probability of the bill's passage in 2026 at around 35%, but recent analyses suggest it has fallen to 18-19%. As expectations for regulatory clarity weaken, vigilance is growing in the cryptocurrency market, including Bitcoin.

Cloture Requires 60 Votes, Republicans Hold 53 Seats... At Least 7 Democratic Votes Needed

The core of the CLARITY Act is to more clearly define the conditions under which cryptocurrencies are classified as securities or commodities, and to divide the supervisory jurisdictions of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). To proceed with full debate in the Senate, the bill must secure 60 votes in a cloture vote. With Republicans holding 53 seats, even if all Republican senators vote in favor, at least 7 Democratic senators must join to reach 60 votes.

The problem is that the opposition front against the bill is not singular. A bipartisan group of 17-18 state attorneys general, led by New York Attorney General Letitia James, reportedly sent a letter to the Senate urging opposition to the bill. They argue that the bill could limit state authority to register and supervise certain cryptocurrency companies at the federal level, potentially weakening states' ability to prevent fraud and protect consumers.

Banking Sector Also Opposes... Debate over Effectiveness of Stablecoin 'Circuit Breaker'

The banking sector has also expressed dissatisfaction with the stablecoin safeguards included in the current bill. Major banking groups believe the so-called stablecoin 'circuit breaker' is designed to trigger only after significant deposit outflows from regional banks, which may limit its effectiveness. Some also argue that the bill fails to sufficiently block the practice of offering interest-like rewards through payment stablecoins. The banking sector's concern is that if stablecoins absorb bank deposits by offering high rewards, it could burden the funding structure of small and regional banks in particular.

Democratic backlash also remains a variable. Republicans reportedly prepared a 635-page amendment reflecting Democratic demands, which reportedly included around 126 Democratic requirements, strengthened ethics rules, and stablecoin safeguards. However, some Democrats argue that the revised ethics rules alone cannot adequately resolve conflict-of-interest issues. How to address consumer protection, illicit finance prevention, and President Trump's cryptocurrency-related interests is also being raised as a sticking point.

Ultimately, the deadlock over the CLARITY Act can be seen not as the result of a single issue, but as the intertwining of state authority, banking interests, stablecoin rewards, consumer protection, illicit finance prevention, and ethics concerns for high-ranking officials all at once.

Passage Odds Fall from 35% to 18-19%... Betting Volume Exceeds $17 Million

Market assessments of the bill's passage have dropped significantly. In cryptocurrency-related prediction markets, analyses showed that after Republicans unveiled the large-scale amendment, the probability of the CLARITY Act's passage in 2026 rose to around 35%. However, as opposition from Democrats and state attorneys general continued, the probability reflected in related contracts reportedly fell to around 18-19%. Betting volume formed around the outcome has also been analyzed to exceed $17 million.

Prediction market probabilities do not represent actual congressional vote outcomes, but rather indicate market participants' expectations expressed as prices. Nevertheless, the drop from 35% to below 20% in a short period can serve as a reference indicator showing that expectations for the bill's passage have weakened considerably.

Bitcoin Hits $79,586 Then Falls Below $78,000

Cryptocurrency prices have also shown movements not unrelated to this atmosphere. Bitcoin recently rose to around $79,586 but was later pushed below $78,000. Previously, the market showed Bitcoin's rally being limited in the $79,000-$80,000 range.

However, it is difficult to explain Bitcoin's recent decline solely by the CLARITY Act. Macroeconomic variables such as the U.S. Federal Reserve's monetary policy decisions and interest rate outlook are simultaneously pressuring the market. A more important change is that expectations of 'securing U.S. regulatory clarity,' which had supported the market, are weakening.

Even If the Bill Fails, Regulation Continues... SEC and CFTC Roles Grow

If the CLARITY Act fails to clear the Senate's 60-vote threshold, uncertainty in U.S. cryptocurrency regulation could persist longer than expected. Some bill supporters predict that if passage fails this session, it will not be easy to push it through again within 2026. Some observers suggest that considering the political calendar, the realistic opportunity to pursue a comprehensive market structure bill could be pushed back for a considerable period. However, this cannot be definitively stated as 'legislation being impossible until 2030.' Depending on congressional negotiations and political circumstances, new bills or amendments could re-emerge.

Even if the CLARITY Act falls through, U.S. cryptocurrency regulation will not stop. Regulators such as the SEC and CFTC can continue their own rulemaking and supervision based on existing laws. SEC Chairman Paul Atkins has also stated that rulemaking work on crypto asset regulation, investment advisers' custody of assets, and related market infrastructure can proceed separately. Therefore, if the bill does not pass, the U.S. cryptocurrency market is likely to continue under a structure where the scope of regulation is determined by SEC and CFTC rules and court rulings, rather than a single market structure law from Congress.

The industry has also raised the possibility that if U.S. legislative uncertainty persists, companies and capital could move to regions with relatively clear digital asset regulatory frameworks, such as the European Union's MiCA, Singapore, and Dubai.

For investors, the deadlock over the CLARITY Act does not immediately mean a cryptocurrency ban or trading halt. Rather, the key risk is that uncertainty over which cryptocurrencies are classified as securities or commodities, which agency supervises them, and what rules apply to exchanges and businesses could persist for a long time.

[This article is a market trend analysis based on provided market data and does not recommend buying or selling any specific cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile assets, and losses and responsibilities from investment lie with the investor. AI assisted with parts of this article.]

Wooil Shim
Staff Reporter

CBC Globe publishes verified stories with editorial review, source checks, and tenant-specific publication standards.