"We Will Not Submit to the Grammys"... BTS's Boycott Declaration Shakes the Grammar of Western Music Hegemony
It was not simply a matter of whether to win an award. The question directed at the Grammys was whether music that originated in Asia, even after achieving global success, must still be evaluated under the separate label of "Asian music." The party who posed that question through the choice of "not

It was not simply a matter of whether to win an award. The question directed at the Grammys was whether music that originated in Asia, even after achieving global success, must still be evaluated under the separate label of "Asian music." The party who posed that question through the choice of "not submitting" rather than direct criticism or a statement was BTS.
■ "We Will Not Submit to the Grammys"... The Simultaneous Declaration of July 29
The seven members moved simultaneously on July 29. Identical posts appeared on each of their Instagram Stories stating that they would not submit their works to this year's Grammy Awards. The message conveyed was concise: before borders of region and language, music should be heard and loved on its own merits. While no specific category was named as the problem, the Grammys had unveiled a new classification method roughly a month before the announcement, so the target of the message naturally drew attention.
■ The Trigger on June 16... Establishment of "Best Asian Pop Music Performance"
The trigger was the Recording Academy's announcement on June 16. From the 69th Grammy Awards onward, a separate category called "Best Asian Pop Music Performance" would judge pop music made in Asian languages, including K-pop and J-pop.
Viewed only as the addition of one award for Asian music, it could have been received as a measure expanding the Grammys' scope. However, looking at the rules applied at the actual submission stage told a different story. This was due to a principle prohibiting the same song from being submitted to two performance categories in the same year. A song directed to the Asian pop category could not also be submitted to general performance categories such as "Best Pop Duo/Group Performance," where BTS had already been nominated three times. It was a point where interpretations inevitably diverged on whether a new door had been opened, or a separate entrance apart from the existing door had been created.
■ The Grammys' Explanation and the Foreign Media's View
Once BTS stated it would not submit its works, the Grammys responded promptly. Harvey Mason Jr., CEO of the Recording Academy, issued a statement the following day expressing disappointment at the news of BTS's non-participation while saying he understood and respected the decision made as creators. Regarding the reason for creating the new category, he explained it was intended to celebrate the growth, diversity, and depth shown by Asian pop music. The Academy's explanation was that there was no intention to push or separate certain musicians into a different domain. He also noted that the general fields, where all genres compete, remain open to all recordings.
However, the explanation alone did not settle the controversy. The Guardian assessed that even though BTS used no strong language, the decision carried clear critical meaning. The Associated Press prominently reported local reactions that a separate Asian pop category could act as a "racialized barrier" for Asian musicians.
■ BTS's "Boycott," Unlike Drake and The Weeknd's
There have been musicians before who raised issues by not submitting works to the Grammys. Drake, The Weeknd, and Morgan Wallen were cited as representative examples. However, even under the same label of "boycott," the reasons were not identical. While those artists mainly expressed distrust of opaque judging methods, in the controversy surrounding BTS, the classification system that separates Asian music into a distinct category emerged as the central issue.
■ ARMY's Chart Response... "Aliens" Tops Charts in 78 Countries
The artists' choice spread to fandom action as well. The song ARMY brought back was "Aliens" from BTS's fifth full-length album "Arirang." A campaign was launched to push the song, which indirectly addresses racism, back up the iTunes charts, and as a result it reached No. 1 on iTunes "Top Songs" charts in 78 countries worldwide. In effect, the fandom responded to the debate over the awards system through chart action.
■ August 14: The Grammys' "Reconsideration"
A bigger change came next. The Recording Academy, which had initially explained the rationale for the new category, brought out the word "reconsideration." On August 14, about two weeks after BTS's announcement, Harvey Mason Jr. issued another statement. The gist was that, regardless of the Academy's intentions in creating the category, it had become clear that some artists felt the category did not properly represent the music they had poured their efforts into creating. Accordingly, the plan to establish the Asian pop category was placed under reconsideration. According to Variety and Billboard, the Recording Academy subsequently contacted Asian musicians to seek their advice and began reviewing how to revise the category.
■ The Gap Between BTS and the Grammys Since 2019
Overlaying these developments with the history between BTS and the Grammys reveals another gap. BTS first made contact with the Grammys in 2019 when they appeared on stage as presenters. In 2020 they participated in a joint performance, and in 2021 and 2022 they were nominated for "Best Pop Duo/Group Performance." In 2023 they were simultaneously nominated in three categories in a single year, including "Best Music Video" and "Album of the Year." Nominations and stage appearances repeated, but no wins came.
This gap persistently followed BTS throughout its Grammy journey. As the group's influence in the global pop music market did not match its Grammy results, debates continued over the criteria by which Asian artists are evaluated. In this controversy, the problem took a different form. Apart from album sales or the number of Billboard No. 1s, the central question became where the Grammy institution would place Asian music and under what name it would classify it.
Views of the same institution also diverged. The creation of a category solely for Asian music could be interpreted as broadening recognition, but the structure preventing simultaneous submission to existing general categories drew the counterargument that it instead placed music inside a separate enclosure. With the Academy ultimately deciding to reconsider the new category plan following BTS's non-participation, this debate went beyond a mere naming issue.
■ An Undetermined Future
That said, what has happened so far cannot be taken to mean the Grammy system has already changed. The Academy has not released the results of its review, the final form of the Asian pop category has not been decided, and how the actual award structure will be composed at the 69th Grammy Awards early next year remains unconfirmed.
There are precedents predating this debate. The Grammys have previously faced criticism over the names and criteria of categories that lumped non-Western music into a single category. Critics pointed out that treating music from different cultural spheres as one category effectively designated certain cultures as "music outside the mainstream." There have also been cases where the Recording Academy later revised the names and classification criteria of relevant categories. Therefore, the questioning of separately grouping non-Western music around region and language did not begin with this incident. It is closer to the truth that a debate the Grammys had repeatedly confronted resurfaced with the appearance of the Asian pop category.
The difference lies in where the discussion has arrived. In the past, adjustments were made by changing the names or criteria of already existing categories; this time, the newly announced category itself was placed under reconsideration before implementation.
Whether BTS's choice will be recorded as the event that actually changed the Grammy classification system remains unknown. With no final decision on the Asian pop category yet made, it is too early to conclude that Western music institutions have changed. However, the sequence is clear: BTS raised the issue by refusing to submit to the new "Asian" category the Grammys had created, and the Recording Academy subsequently began reexamining its original plan. Whether that crack leads to institutional change or is resealed after the controversy will be confirmed by the Grammys' final choice.
[This content is an article highlighting stars nominated for the Netizens' Awards. The Netizens' Awards is an online fan voting platform that does not sell voting rights and provides equal voting opportunities to all users. Rankings are determined by fans' voluntary and consistent participation rather than capital, and the cumulative 78 million votes are a record of pure fan devotion built from each individual fan's choice. This article was partially assisted by AI.]
CBC Globe publishes verified stories with editorial review, source checks, and tenant-specific publication standards.
![November Globe Netizen Awards Drama Category Vote: 'Takryu' Leads... '21st Century Grand Prince's Wife' and 'Eerie Romance' in Pursuit [Second-Half Final Round]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.cbcglobe.com%2Ftenants%2Fcbc00000-0000-4000-8000-000000000001%2Fmedia%2Fcbc%2F2026%2F11%2F627729%2F7183a24309b00102%2Fvariants%2Fhero.webp&w=1920&q=75)