Entertainment/Home · Entertainment

Hwang Young-woong, Jung Seo-joo, Hong Ji-yoon, and Kim Yong-bin's 'Hateful Love' Covers Compared: Four Emotions and the October Netizen Awards Rankings

The 'Mi-un-sarang' (Hateful Love) covers sung by singers Hwang Young-woong, Jung Seo-joo, Hong Ji-yoon, and Kim Yong-bin demonstrate how a single song can be reborn with such diverse emotions. Although the four sing the same song, they differ in voice, breath control, and the way they convey emotion

Jonghoon Jeong
Staff Reporter
16 min read
Hwang Young-woong, Jung Seo-joo, Hong Ji-yoon, and Kim Yong-bin's 'Hateful Love' Covers Compared: Four Emotions and the October Netizen Awards Rankings
CBC News

The 'Mi-un-sarang' (Hateful Love) covers sung by singers Hwang Young-woong, Jung Seo-joo, Hong Ji-yoon, and Kim Yong-bin demonstrate how a single song can be reborn with such diverse emotions. Although the four sing the same song, they differ in voice, breath control, and the way they convey emotion, adding to the pleasure of watching their stages one after another. Notably, the four singers are each receiving fans' attention in different positions in the October Netizen Awards. As of the afternoon of the 13th, Hwang Young-woong is leading the Male Singer category, Jung Seo-joo is running first in the Female Singer category, Hong Ji-yoon ranks 10th in the Female Singer category, and Kim Yong-bin sits at 11th in the Neo Star category.

A Song of Love You Cannot Let Go of, Even While Hating

From its very title, 'Hateful Love' embodies a love that cannot easily be untangled. The feeling of being unable to fully let go despite trying to hate, and of memories growing more vivid the more you try to forget, runs throughout the song. Love and resentment, longing and resignation are intertwined, so the impression of the song changes depending on which emotion the singer chooses to emphasize.

Hwang Young-woong – Weighty Longing, a Stage Like a Recollection

Hwang Young-woong's 'Hateful Love' draws the ear to the weighty sentiment expressed by a male vocalist. The emotion beginning in the lower register and the resonance deepening as the song progresses evoke the heart of someone unable to easily shake off love. Rather than pouring out emotion all at once, he leaves space between the lyrics, allowing the song's narrative to unfold calmly. Lingering attachment and longing, rather than fierce resentment, come to the fore first, and even the seemingly composed passages carry an emotion that never fully settles, making the song feel like a personal recollection. With this deep emotional delivery, Hwang Young-woong has built his own musical world and currently holds the lead in the October Netizen Awards' Male Singer category. Attention is also on how fans' interest will flow as the ranking competition continues.

Jung Seo-joo – Tenderness Brought to Life Within Restraint

Jung Seo-joo's 'Hateful Love' is a cover worth listening to closely for its delicate emotional line. With her clear voice, she unfolds the lyrics without letting the sadness within the song slip away lightly. Tenderness comes alive within restrained expression, conveying the sentiment of someone who knows they must let go of love yet whose heart still lingers in that place. Not only the moments where her voice soars, but also the quieter passages where emotion is sustained are key listening points; following each syllable and phrase, one senses her focus on delivering the words fully rather than displaying flashy technique. The meeting of a young voice with the sentiment of long-lasting love gives the familiar song a new atmosphere. Jung Seo-joo maintains first place in the October Netizen Awards' Female Singer category, and her musical charm of carrying deep tenderness within a clear tone resonates with fans' interest.

Hong Ji-yoon – Vivid Tone, Emotional Contours

In Hong Ji-yoon's 'Hateful Love,' a vivid voice and emotional contours drive the flow of the song. She clearly reveals the sorrow and poignancy held by the song's narrator while powerfully carrying the overall melody forward. Her expression, as if finally bringing out words long held in the heart, allows listeners to quickly connect with the lyrics' emotion. She makes us examine the moments where lingering attachment and resentment toward love intersect, and the interplay of her bright, vivid tone with the sorrowful words creates scenes where different emotions surge simultaneously. Hong Ji-yoon currently sits at 10th place in the October Netizen Awards' Female Singer category. In the same category where Jung Seo-joo leads, she is demonstrating her presence with her own color, and for fans who remember her signature refreshing vocals and vivid emotional expression, this ranking is a point from which to watch for future changes.

Kim Yong-bin – The Poignancy of Authentic Trot

Kim Yong-bin's 'Hateful Love' draws attention to the emotional delivery style inherent in authentic trot. He controls his breath along the flow of the lyrics and adds power to his voice at key moments to reveal the song's poignancy. His expression, as if squarely facing the heart of someone who cannot forget a love, heightens the song's immersion. His handling of the beginning and end of each phrase also draws interest, as the interplay between sections where emotion is drawn out long and sections where power is eased creates a flow in which a person's past love seems to unfold again on stage. Kim Yong-bin is ranked 11th in the October Netizen Awards' Neo Star category. His voice, which captures the deep flavor of authentic trot, is a listening point that distinguishes him from the other three singers, and while there is a gap to the top ranks, the ongoing competition means the future flow remains open.

The Joy of Comparative Listening, Fan Hearts Extending to the Rankings

Listening to the four covers in turn makes it even clearer that 'Hateful Love' is not a song carrying just one emotion. In Hwang Young-woong's voice we find weighty longing, in Jung Seo-joo's song delicate tenderness, in Hong Ji-yoon's cover vivid sorrow, and in Kim Yong-bin's stage the deep-running sentiment of authentic trot. Even the same lyrics place a different emotion at the center depending on who sings them. On one stage, resentment toward the person who left looms large; on another, the confession of still being in love arrives first; and in yet another cover, resignation toward accepting the breakup or regret over time that cannot be reclaimed may be felt most deeply.

A cover stage does not end with simply following the original melody. The moment a singer's voice, breath, and emotional expression are added, the song takes on a new story, and the deeper the layers of emotion in a song like 'Hateful Love,' the more pronounced these differences become. The essence of comparative listening is not determining who sang better. The meaning lies in the process of examining which emotion each singer used to interpret the same passage and what temperature their voice carries; depending on one's own experiences and memories, the singer and phrase that linger longest in the heart may differ for each listener.

These differences also connect to how people view the Netizen Awards. Just as the emotions felt on stage differ from person to person, the singers fans hold in their hearts and the ways they show support are also diverse. With Hwang Young-woong and Jung Seo-joo at the top of the Male and Female Singer categories respectively, the ranking changes that Hong Ji-yoon and Kim Yong-bin may show are also a point of interest. Current rankings do not determine each artist's musical value, but the fact that fans' interest appears in numbers adds meaning to the competition.

The single song 'Hateful Love' takes on different hues as it meets these four singers. Male and female voices cross, and different depths and expressions of emotion come together, creating a reason to listen to one song multiple times. The complex heart—loving while hating, waiting even after being left, resolving to forget yet remembering again—manifests differently in each voice, and this is the listening point that makes 'Hateful Love' enduring. Though their rankings differ, what they share is that the affection for their songs adds another layer of warmth to the awards competition. Attention now turns to what results the fans' hearts for these four singers will bring in the remaining ranking race.

[This article is a review piece written about the 'Hateful Love' covers by Hwang Young-woong, Jung Seo-joo, Hong Ji-yoon, and Kim Yong-bin. Expressions regarding vocal performance may vary depending on the listener's experience and do not imply the superiority of any particular singer. This article was written with the assistance of AI.]

Jonghoon Jeong
Staff Reporter

CBC Globe publishes verified stories with editorial review, source checks, and tenant-specific publication standards.